Rowing Machine vs Treadmill for Weight Loss

rowing machine or treadmill to lose weight

Regular exercise is a great way to stay fit and active, but busy schedules can make gym time hard to find. That’s why many people turn to home fitness equipment. When it comes to weight loss, though, choosing between a rowing machine and a treadmill can be tricky.

This article will give you all the information you need to make the right choice between a treadmill and a rower. By looking at key factors, you’ll get a clear idea of which one suits your fitness goals and preferences best.

Rowing Machine or Treadmill: What Are the Common Benefits?

Whether a person chooses a rowing machine or treadmill for weight loss, both make for an incredible workout and will:

  • Strengthen the heart and lungs;
  • Increase bone capital;
  • Reduce stress;
  • Improve mood;
  • Reduce the risk of heart disease;
  • Increase overall energy levels;
  • Improve the quality of sleep;
  • Burn calories and help to lose fat.

Rowing Machine or Treadmill: What Are the Differences?

A key difference is that a rowing machine works 90% of your muscles, while a treadmill primarily targets the lower body. However, running on a treadmill burns more calories than a rower.

The rowing machine is excellent for building muscle mass, making it more effective than running for muscle strengthening. It targets both upper and lower body muscles at the same time, promoting a balanced and harmonious physique. While the rower engages nearly all your muscles, the treadmill excels at burning calories, especially when used with an incline for added intensity.

Nevertheless, if you want to lose weight comprehensively, choose a rowing machine. It will provide a cardio workout similar to a treadmill and help build muscle. The rower is great for weight loss because it boosts your metabolism for hours, even after your workout ends.

Rowing Machine or Treadmill: Which One is Better for the Body?

Both rowing machines and treadmills offer low-impact workouts, making them easy on the body while still providing effective exercise.  Indeed, running is not the best sporting activity for preserving the joints. However, if you want to use a treadmill for walking, you will have no problem with this.

Studies indicate that runners can exert four to eight times their body weight on their joints with each stride. This impact can lead to serious joint damage, particularly for those who are overweight.

On the other hand, a rowing machine is a low-impact ergometer, meaning it doesn’t put stress on your joints, regardless of how intense your workout is. Since rowing involves less resistance against gravity, your joints aren’t subjected to harsh impacts. This makes the rowing machine ideal for recovering from injuries or surgery, as it’s commonly used in rehabilitation to help regain strength. If high-impact workouts are not an option for you, the rower is definitely the best choice.

Rowing machine

Fat loss occurs when your body burns more calories than it consumes over time. About 70% of this process relies on maintaining a healthy, balanced diet, while the remaining 30% comes from regular physical activity. If you’ve rowed before, you’ll find yourself on familiar ground with this exercise. The rowing machine engages 90% of your muscles and offers numerous benefits, including improved endurance, better heart rate regulation, and overall body toning.

Looking to lose weight? The rowing machine is ideal for shedding calories more quickly than other fitness equipment. When practiced with intensity and regularity, indoor rowing can burn between 250 and 700 calories in just one hour. The exact amount depends on factors like age, sex, size, and session intensity.

However, using a rowing machine demands more technique and understanding of movement mechanics compared to a treadmill. It’s crucial to learn how to use the rower properly to maximize your results. Good coordination is essential to prevent injuries. Additionally, if you have back, neck, or knee pain, indoor rowing may not be the best choice for you.

Treadmill

A treadmill offers the flexibility to facilitate weight loss through walking or running indoors at a personalized pace. This versatile fitness machine primarily targets the lower body muscles. Users can expect to tone and strengthen various muscle groups, including the thighs, lumbar muscles, calves, and gluteal muscles.

For weight loss, a treadmill is an excellent option, especially for those looking to shed fat and those with weakened joints. Its smooth surface provides better cushioning than outdoor surfaces like dirt or grass, reducing impact and making workouts more comfortable. However, make sure to have a healthy and balanced diet. It is an endurance sport that requires prolonged and constant effort.

Using a treadmill also helps improve your cardiovascular and respiratory fitness while promoting fat burning. Depending on your weight and workout intensity, you can burn between 700 and 1,000 calories per hour. The harder you push yourself, the more calories you’ll burn!

To achieve long-lasting results, it’s important to run regularly on the treadmill. To boost your weight loss, consider adjusting the incline; the steeper the incline, the more calories you’ll burn. The best way to maximize calorie burn is to work out within your target heart rate zone.

The ideal heart rate zone for fat burning is between 60% and 70% of your maximum heart rate (MHR). For women, the MHR is calculated as 226 minus your age, while for men, it’s 200 minus your age. Once you have your MHR, multiply it by 60% and 70% to find your target heart rate zone for optimal fat burning.

Rowing Machine Vs Treadmill for Weight Loss?

Choosing between a rowing machine and a treadmill for weight loss ultimately comes down to personal preferences and goals. It’s difficult to say that one is definitively better than the other, as it depends on various factors we’ve discussed. However, rowing is incredibly efficient, engaging 90% of your muscles while allowing for fat loss without putting stress on your joints. It’s a great option for home workouts, maximizing fat burn and strengthening muscles without risking injury. Just be sure to learn the proper technique to avoid any discomfort.

On the other hand, a treadmill is also a reliable choice for weight loss, focusing more on the lower body and offering a safe way to burn calories. Regardless of your choice, both machines are effective tools for achieving weight loss goals.


Similar Articles:

Rowing Program for Weight Loss

Spin Bike vs Elliptical: Which One Choose

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *